Independent Validation & Business Case Support

You already have an answer. Is it strong enough to invest in?

ETA provides independent specialist review when operators need confidence that an internal study,
vendor proposal or preliminary compression concept is technically robust, commercially defensible
and suitable for management or procurement approval.

  • Independent of OEMs
  • Model & assumption challenge
  • CAPEX / OPEX comparison
  • Decision-support output

The core question

Can management trust this recommendation
enough to act?

Technical

Are the models, assumptions and
engineering conclusions robust?

Commercial

Does the option justify its CAPEX and
OPEX?

Organisational

Can the recommendation move into
approval and procurement?

Why Independent Validation Matters

Sometimes the problem is not lack of analysis. It is lack of confidence.

Operators may already have internal engineering, a consultant's study or an
OEM proposal—but still need confidence that the recommendation reflects the
complete production system and operator interests.

Independent review can be particularly valuable before FID, procurement or
commitment to major compressor CAPEX.

You may be asking...

  • Are our internal conclusions technically sound?
  • Has the production or network model been properly validated?
  • Are vendor assumptions realistic?
  • Have credible alternatives been considered?
  • Are CAPEX and OPEX comparisons consistent?
  • Is the recommended compression timing justified?
  • What evidence does management need for approval?
  • Can procurement act on the current definition?
Typical Triggers

When an independent answer
adds most value

Internal Study

The team has already
identified a preferred option

But management wants external verification
before proceeding.

Vendor Proposal

An OEM has proposed a
technical solution

But the operator wants to know whether it is
optimal for the wider field and production system.

FID

Engineering needs to become
an investment decision

CAPEX, OPEX, production benefit and
implementation risk must be brought together in a
defensible recommendation.

How ETA Helps

Challenge the answer before the
organisation commits to it

REV

Review the Existing Work

Examine study scope, assumptions, models,
calculations and the logic behind the
recommendation.

MOD

Validate Models

Challenge production, network and compressor
models against available operating or forecast
data.

ALT

Test Alternatives

Determine whether credible technical options
were excluded or insufficiently evaluated.

£

Compare Commercial
Implications

Review CAPEX, OPEX, production benefit,
timing and cost-benefit assumptions.

RISK

Identify Decision Risk

Highlight assumptions or uncertainties that could
materially change the recommendation.

GO

Provide a Clear
Recommendation

Translate the review into a concise route forward
for management, project and procurement
stakeholders.

Typical Decision Path

From “we think this is right” to
“we can defend this decision”

01

Frame the Decision

Define what management or
procurement actually needs to
decide.

02

Review Evidence

Assess data, models,
assumptions and previous
engineering.

03

Challenge Alternatives

Test whether the option set and
conclusions are complete.

04

Quantify

Compare technical, production
and commercial implications.

05

Recommend

Provide a clear independent
decision-support position.

What You Leave With

Independent confidence and a
clearer investment decision

Independent technical review

Strengths, weaknesses and gaps in existing work.

Validated assumptions

Key modelling and design inputs independently
challenged.

Alternative comparison

Evidence that credible technical options were
considered.

CAPEX / OPEX view

Consistent comparison of investment alternatives.

Decision risks

Material uncertainties and sensitivities made visible.

Recommended route forward

A concise position suitable for management and
procurement.

The Value of Independence

The deliverable may be technical.
The benefit is confidence.

Typical Client Situation

“We know what we think the
answer is.”

“But we want an independent specialist to verify it before
we commit.”

Independent engineering provides a different kind
of value.

ETA has no commercial interest in selling a particular compressor package or EPC
solution. Recommendations can therefore be tested against production, reliability, project
and economic objectives from the operator's perspective.

Desired Outcome

An independently verified answer that management can approve,
procurement can act on and the engineering team can defend.

How This Is Delivered

Independent
validation can cut
across more than one
ETA service

The right methodology depends on what is being validated: future
compression strategy, debottlenecking, compressor health or a
FEED/procurement decision.

Relevant methodologies

Extraclarity™ CONCEPTCOMPRESSOR™ modgas™ CompressorDoc™ verify™

The methodology is secondary to the decision. ETA first defines
what must be independently established and then selects the
appropriate engineering scope.

Need a second opinion before
committing compression CAPEX?

Share the existing study, proposal or recommendation and the decision your organisation needs to
make. ETA can help determine what level of independent validation is appropriate.

Request an Independent Review →